Subscribe

Search Results

You can quote several words to match them as a full term:
"some text to search"
otherwise, the single words will be understood as distinct search terms.
ANY of the entered words would match

Bookmarks

From ... in Biology —

Alkaline Water or Hydrogen Water — Which One Is Better?

Editor's Note: This article is a reprint.

Alkaline Water or Hydrogen Water — Which One Is Better?

It was originally published November 12, 2018. Alkaline water is experiencing a resurgence in popularity with sales jumping from $47 million in 2014 to $427 million in 2017. Marketers claim alkaline water can correct excess acidity in your tissues, which can then prevent or reverse cancer, arthritis and other degenerative diseases.

12

However, there's virtually no good evidence to support such claims, and I warned people about drinking alkaline water on a regular basis over eight years ago. Molecular hydrogen, on the other hand, does have a number of health benefits, some of which mirror the claims made for alkaline water — and there's a really good reason for that. So, here, I'll review these two types of waters, and the scientific support (or lack thereof) for each of them, and how the benefits of molecular hydrogen were inappropriately transferred over to alkaline water — primarily due to ignorance.

What Is Alkaline Water?

Alkaline water is water that has gone through electrolysis that separates it into alkaline and acid fractions. The theory behind alkaline water is that alkaline (ionized) water is a powerful antioxidant with surplus electrons that can "mop up" dangerous free radicals. As reported by Arwa Mahdawi in The Guardian:

"Dr. Tanis Fenton, an adjunct professor at the University of Calgary and anevidence analyst for Dietitians of Canada, told me that the marketing claimsbehind alkaline water are based on an old idea called the acid-ash hypothesis.This posits that eating certain food like meat, dairy and eggs results insomething called acid ash in your body, which increases your acid levels andcauses adverse health effects including osteoporosis.In 2002, an alternative medicine practitioner called Robert O. Young spun theacid-ash hypothesis into a fad alkaline diet, with a popular series of bookscalled the pH Miracle.According to these books, an alkaline diet could treat all manner of woes, frompoor digestion to cancer. Young, by the way, was sentenced to three years in jailin 2017 for practicing medicine without a license."

According to Fenton — author of a systematic review of the association between alkaline water and cancer — the few studies showing positive results with alkaline water

345

are poorly designed, leading him to conclude that "there is no rigorous evidence" showing that alkaline water produces health benefits. This view is shared by Randy Johnson — who has a master of science degree in molecular genetics — whose evaluation of the evidence can be found on his Cyber Nook website page, "Drinking Water Resources: A Review of the Evidence Alleged to Support Health Benefits of Alkaline Water."

Why Alkaline Water Doesn't Work

One of the key reasons why the consumption of alkaline water cannot confer the health benefits associated with alkalinity is because you cannot alter the pH of your blood and body this way. As noted by Fenton:

"Your body regulates its [blood] pH in a very narrow range because all ourenzymes are designed to work at pH 7.4. If our pH varied too much we wouldn'tsurvive."

Your diet, including the water you drink, can however alter the pH of your urine. Urine is typically acidic, with a pH around 6, and this is actually a sign that your kidneys are working properly. As for the benefits people report when drinking alkaline water, Fenton suggests the placebo effect may be at play. Initial improvement can also be attributed to detoxification and/or improved hydration in general, simply from drinking more water. Lastly, alkaline water is often correlated with having a higher mineral concentration, which is known to have beneficial effects, particularly when dietary intake from food is low.

Understanding pH

The concept of the acidity or alkalinity of your body — or of water — is based on the pH scale. What is pH? It's simply a measure of the concentration of hydrogen ions. In fact, the acronym "pH" is short for "potential of hydrogen."

678910

The higher a liquid's pH, the fewer free hydrogen ions (H+) it has; the lower its pH, the more free hydrogen ions (H+) it has. One pH unit refiects a tenfold change in ion concentration, so there are 10 times as many hydrogen ions available at a pH of 7 than at a pH of 8. The pH scale goes from 0 to 14, and a pH of 7 is neutral. Anything with a pH below 7 is considered acidic, and anything with a pH above 7 is alkaline (or basic). But the real reason why alkaline water is a scam is that it has no buffers to maintain its pH. The instant the alkaline water hits your very acidic stomach, the pH is neutralized as there are no buffers. Truly alkaline water would have an alkaline buffer like baking soda (sodium bicarbonate), which is also our body's natural alkaline buffer. Some have claimed that as the stomach acid neutralizes the alkaline water, the bicarbonate ions are released into the blood and thus it has an alkalizing effect. This would be true if the alkaline water effectively neutralized all the stomach acid (like baking soda would), but alkaline water doesn't neutralize any significant quantity of stomach acid; the stomach acid completely neutralizes the alkaline water. So, there is no "net alkalizing effect." Natural water on our planet ranges in pH from around 6.5 to 8.5, depending on surrounding soil and vegetation, seasonal variations and weather, and even time of day responses to sunlight. Human activities further infiuence the pH of our water, from the barrage of toxic industrial pollutants. Most aquatic animals and plants have adapted to life in water with a very specific pH and will die from even slight changes. For example, Michigan State University found that when the pH of greenhouse media is too high (greater than 6.5), it increases the chances of micronutrient deficiencies in the plants, and too low of a pH (less than 5.3) results in calcium and/or magnesium and/or manganese toxicity. Similarly, Ohio State University Extension Service reports that alkaline water affects a plant's ability to obtain nutrients from the soil and can alter the soil's pH over time. Your body also requires a relatively stable pH, or else you'll run into problems. This was

11121314

demonstrated in a Swedish well water study, which found both pH extremes to be problematic. Notably, pH appears to have a major infiuence on your mitochondria . Research has shown normal cells die under extremely alkaline conditions, as a result of altering mitochondrial function. So, as noted by Fenton, "alkaline water is a solution to a problem that doesn't need solving." Indeed, it makes sense that you are designed to drink water that occurs naturally, which excludes alkaline water with pH levels of 9.5 and above.

Early Days of Hydrogen Water Production

Interestingly, aside from Young taking the acid-ash hypothesis and running with it, there's another piece of history that helps explain why the alkaline water myth gained hold. The Molecular Hydrogen Institute explains the history of electrolyzed reduced water or ERW (the most common term used for alkaline water in the scientific literature):

"Studies on ERW began in the 1930s in Japan, and in 1965 the JapaneseMinistry of Health, Labor and Welfare approved ERW as a medical substancewith potential to improve gastrointestinal symptoms …Over the ensuing decades, anecdotal and scientific evidence accumulatedsubstantiating many other benefits of ERW such as: protecting DNA fromradical damage, increasing glucose uptake, improving diabetes, preventingpremature cell death, offering liver protection, preventing lipid oxidation andothers. However, it was uncertain as to how ERW was producing these benefits."

Unfortunately, this is how the misunderstanding about pH came about. However, as noted by the Institute, "It is now well-recognized that the primary agent responsible for the benefits is attributed to the dissolved molecular hydrogen gas." So, in a nutshell, the benefits, when there are any, are actually due to the presence of molecular hydrogen,

15161718

and has nothing to do with the pH of the water. Dr. Kyu-Jae Lee, a hydrogen gas researcher, says:

"In the 1990s I began studying alkaline ionized water and published scientificarticles on its antioxidant, anticancer and antidiabetic effects, but did not reallyunderstand why the water worked. It was dificult to believe. Upon furtherinvestigation, I have now confirmed that the benefits from the alkaline ionizedwater are attributed to the hydrogen gas produced during electrolysis."

Another researcher, Mami Noda, Ph.D., adds:

"[B]y testing every variable of the water (e.g., minerals, pH, H2, etc.), it was clearthat only H2 was exerting the benefit … Our 2009 publication of an MPTP-induced mouse model of Parkinson's disease also showed beneficial effectsfrom H2.We later discovered that the benefits in this model were mediated by H2-induced gastric ghrelin secretion via a ß1 adrenergic receptor-dependentpathway. Although hydrogen's effect in Parkinson's disease has now beenconfirmed in a human clinical trial, more research is necessary to reveal themolecular mechanisms responsible for the therapeutic benefits of H2.Because of hydrogen's high safety profile, ease of administration and itspromising medical effects, I feel obligated as a pharmacologist to continue myinvestigations of H2 as a novel medical gas."

What Is Molecular Hydrogen?

Molecular hydrogen (H2) — two hydrogen atoms combined together — is a gas with very unique and selective antioxidant effects that specifically target the most harmful free radicals. It works primarily by improving and optimizing the redox status of the cell when needed.

1920

As a result, you see improvements in superoxide dismutase, catalase and glutathione levels, for example. Not only does hydrogen selectively reduce the most toxic radicals, but it can help prevent an excess (which becomes toxic) of the free radicals from being produced in the first place. This is a very powerful prevention mechanism. H2 also activates the Nrf2 pathway when needed. Nrf2 is a transcription factor that, when activated, goes into the cell's nucleus and binds to the antioxidant response element in the DNA. It then induces the transcription of further cytoprotective enzymes such as glutathione, superoxide dismutase catalase, glutathione peroxidase, phase II enzymes, heme-1 oxygenase and many others. A landmark paper on molecular hydrogen came out in Nature Medicine in 2007, showing 2% hydrogen gas was effective at preventing brain damage from ischemia reperfusion and, as an antioxidant, has powerful therapeutic applications. Hydrogen is the smallest molecule in the universe, and is neutral and nonpolar, which is why its bioavailability is so great. It does not dissociate into its electrons and protons when dissolved in water, so it will not alter the pH of water or your body and has nothing to do with the alkaline water concept. More than 1,000 peer-reviewed scientific publications have collectively demonstrated that H2 has therapeutic potential in over 170 different human and animal disease models. In fact, hydrogen is shown to benefit virtually every organ of the human body, and the reason for this is because hydrogen actually targets and mitigates the root causes of infiammation and oxidation. To learn more about the details of how molecular hydrogen works, see " The Remarkable Benefits of Molecular Hydrogen ," in which I interview a world-class expert and researcher in this field, Tyler W. LeBaron. I've also included that interview below for your convenience.

Hydrogen Water Versus Hydrogen Peroxide

21

Due to the similarity in names, many confuse hydrogen water with hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), and I often get asked if one can get the benefits of molecular hydrogen by drinking hydrogen peroxide in water. This is a dangerous mistake to make, so let me make this point abundantly clear: Never ingest hydrogen peroxide (3% solution). Hydrogen peroxide (3% solution) — the stuff you use to disinfect wounds — is not the same as molecular hydrogen or hydrogen (H2) water. Hydrogen peroxide is for topical use only. You could potentially use it is as a mouth rinse for gingivitis, provided you spit it out and do not swallow, and you can pour a few drops into your ear canal as a remedy to combat cold and fiu symptoms. But you should never ingest hydrogen peroxide. Another common misconception is that adding hydrogen to water will form hydrogen peroxide. As explained by the Molecular Hydrogen Institute:

"Water has the chemical formula H2O, and hydrogen peroxide has the chemicalformula H2O2, which by comparison contains an extra oxygen, not hydrogen.So, it does not, indeed it cannot, form hydrogen peroxide.The fact is, hydrogen gas does not bond to or react with the water molecules, itjust dissolves into the water. It does not create some novel molecule like H4O,which would in fact be chemically impossible to form.Therefore, hydrogen water and hydrogen peroxide are completely differentsubstances. Furthermore, hydrogen peroxide cannot be used to generate H2gas or make hydrogen-rich water."

Alkaline Versus Alkalinity

Yet another source of confusion is the issue of alkaline versus alkalinity. These two words are not interchangeable, as from a scientific standpoint as they refer to different things. This too may be part of why people have placed such undue value on alkaline water. As explained by Mark Timmons, CEO of U.S. Water Systems:

2223
"To alkalize your body means that you give the body the ability to maintain aproper pH, but in order to do that you need water with alkalinity not alkalinewater. pH merely measures the degree of acidity or alkalinity, not the capacity toneutralize acid … You also don't alkalize your body based upon pH, but rather onalkalinity.Alkalinity measures the ability to neutralize acid with buffers which are the sumof bicarbonates. Alkalinity is measured in mg/L (milligrams per liter). Alkalinemineral compounds include … calcium, potassium, magnesium, sodium,manganese [and] iron. So, you need to add alkalinity to your body, but you needto realize that pH has no relation to that alkalinity.Case in point: Spinach juice has a pH of 6.4 but alkalinity of 2,250 mg/L … If youput one-half teaspoon of baking soda into a glass of water, you would have1,500 mg/L of alkalinity. Compare that to one of the many alkaline filters on themarket. Most add just a few mg/L of alkalinity and then it only lasts a fewgallons."

Alkaline Water Is an Unlikely Cancer Preventive

One of the purported health benefits of drinking alkaline water is cancer prevention. However, much of the research really argues against alkalinity when it comes to treating cancer. According to Robert Gillies, who has studied tumor formation and acidity at the Mofitt Cancer Center, tumors make their own acidity by their very nature, and they do this even in an alkaline cellular structure. Scientists developing anticancer agent prototypes that selectively kill tumor cells by interfering with the regulation of intracellular pH also report that alkaline treatments do not have the desired effect, whereas strongly acidic treatments do! Even more interesting is a 2005 study by the National Cancer Institute, which revisits the use of vitamin C (ascorbic acid) to treat cancer. They found that, in pharmacologic

242526

doses administered intravenously, ascorbic acid successfully killed cancer cells without harming normal cells. This is yet another example of cancer cells being vulnerable to acidity, as opposed to alkalinity. So, it seems clear that the relationship between alkalinity and cancer has been grossly oversimplified by those jumping to premature conclusions.

Molecular Hydrogen Is Highly Beneficial for Your Health

In summary, it's unlikely that drinking alkaline water will do you much good. You're probably just wasting your money. Hydrogen water, on the other hand, when consumed on a daily basis, has wide-ranging health benefits. I use it myself regularly. Hydrogen can be obtained from various inhalation devices, hydrogen-producing tablets and ready-to-drink hydrogen beverages in cans (not plastic). For more ins and outs of molecular hydrogen, its actions and therapeutic potential, and information on how to ensure you're getting a quality product, see my interview with LeBaron .

Read the full article at the original website

References:

Related content

Subscribe to The Article Feed

Don’t miss out on the latest articles. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only articles.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe